Allstate vs State Farm Compared (2026): How They Stack Up on Price and Coverage
Key Takeaways
- State Farm is cheaper for nearly every driver profile. $2,204/yr vs Allstate’s $2,941 — a $737 gap that holds for clean records, teens, seniors, and DUIs. Poor credit is the one consistent exception where Allstate prices lower.
- State Farm scores higher on satisfaction and complaints. J.D. Power 2025 claims: 716 vs 691. Lower NAIC complaint index relative to size. Top-five regional rankings vs below-average for Allstate.
- Allstate wins on coverage breadth. Gap insurance, new car replacement, accident forgiveness as a standard feature, Milewise pay-per-mile, and specialty add-ons State Farm doesn’t match. State Farm doesn’t sell gap at all — a real gap for anyone financing or leasing.
- The teen and DUI gaps are unusually wide. A 16-year-old runs $208/mo at State Farm vs $371/mo at Allstate. After a DUI: $65/mo vs $152/mo. Steer Clear adds more savings for under-25 drivers that Allstate can’t match.
- Bottom line: State Farm is the default cheaper quote; Allstate fits specific scenarios. Poor credit, gap coverage needs, Milewise pay-per-mile, new car replacement, or wanting accident forgiveness as standard are the cases where Allstate’s higher premium pays off.
Allstate and State Farm are the two largest agent-driven car insurance companies in the U.S. Both run national agent networks. Both sell auto insurance, home insurance, and life insurance under one roof. Both have been household names for decades. Both insurance policies have nationwide brand recognition.
However, across the categories shoppers actually compare on, the Allstate vs State Farm matchup shows a clear pattern.
State Farm car insurance tends to be cheaper than Allstate car insurance for nearly every driver profile. State Farm scores higher on most major customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction studies published in 2024 and 2025. State Farm receives fewer customer complaints relative to its size on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) complaint index. The Illinois-based insurance company also tends to come in lower on home insurance pricing. The Allstate vs State Farm rate gap is wide enough that for most shoppers, State Farm car insurance shows up as the cheaper quote before any details get compared.
State Farm tends to lead on price. Allstate tends to lead on coverage features.
Allstate insurance gets its edge from what’s bundled inside the car insurance policy: gap coverage, accident forgiveness for all customers, new car replacement, Deductible Rewards, sound system protection, and a pay per mile program called Milewise that the Illinois insurer doesn’t match. State Farm doesn’t sell traditional gap insurance at all, a coverage point worth noting for households financing or leasing. If specialty add-ons matter more than the rate gap, Allstate insurance can be the more practical pick despite the higher premium. State Farm car insurance averages $2,204/yr against Allstate’s $2,941 (per U.S. News). Both run above the $2,012 national average for car insurance. The $737/yr gap holds across nearly every driver profile, with one exception: poor credit, where Allstate often posts cheaper average rates.
Allstate vs State Farm at a glance
| Category | State Farm | Allstate |
| Average annual auto premium | $2,204 | $2,941 |
| Average annual home insurance premium | $2,415 | $2,715 |
| Average renters insurance | ~$13/mo | ~$21/mo |
| AM Best financial strength | A+ (downgraded from A++ Nov 2025) | A+ |
| Market share (auto) | ~16% (#1) | ~10% (#4) |
| Local agents | 19,000+ | ~10,000 |
| J.D. Power 2025 Auto Claims Satisfaction | 716 (above 700 avg) | 691 (below avg) |
| J.D. Power 2025 Auto Insurance Study | Top 5 in most regions | Below average in most regions |
| NAIC auto complaint index | Below average for size | Above average for size |
| Telematics program | Drive Safe & Save (won’t raise rates) | Drivewise (can raise rates) |
| Pay-per-mile option | No | Yes (Milewise) |
| Gap insurance | No | Yes |
| Accident forgiveness | Add-on, not for all | Standard for all customers |
| New car replacement | No | Yes |
| Defensive driving course discount | Yes | No |
| Cheaper average rates for | Most drivers, including teens, DUIs, clean records | Drivers with poor credit; drivers wanting specialty add-ons |
| Not available for new auto policies in | Massachusetts, Rhode Island | California (home only) |
Sources: U.S. News, Compare.com, NerdWallet, AutoInsurance.com, and J.D. Power 2025 studies. Your actual car insurance quotes will vary based on state, driving history, vehicle, and coverage limits.
Cost: Allstate vs State Farm average rates compared
The price gap is the single most-cited reason shoppers in published reviews land on State Farm car insurance. The Allstate vs State Farm rate spread is one of the widest among any two large auto insurers in the country. The Illinois insurer posts cheaper average rates in every driver profile measured except one.
| Driver profile | State Farm avg | Allstate avg | Lower-rate option |
| Clean record, good credit | $47/mo | $87 to $228/mo | State Farm |
| 16-year-old standalone | $208/mo | $371/mo | State Farm |
| 65-year-old standalone | $47/mo | $86/mo | State Farm |
| After a DUI | $65/mo | $152/mo | State Farm |
| Poor credit | Higher | Lower | Allstate |
| Minimum coverage policy | $86/mo avg | $87/mo avg | Roughly even |
| Full coverage policy | $109/mo avg | $228/mo avg | State Farm |
Rates from Quote.com, Insurify, and WalletHub. State Farm’s national average for full coverage runs about 18% below the typical major insurance company per The Zebra. Allstate sits at the high end of major auto insurers nationally.
The teen drivers gap is unusually large: State Farm averages $622/yr less than Allstate for drivers under 20, with a 16-year-old at $208/mo on average versus $371/mo at Allstate. The DUI gap is wider still: $65/mo at State Farm (the lowest among major auto insurance companies) versus $152/mo at Allstate (the highest). The single exception is poor credit, where Allstate’s underwriting weights credit differently and produces cheaper car insurance quotes for low credit scores. The same pattern shows up in homeowners insurance.
Customer satisfaction and claims: where State Farm scores higher in published studies
Across most major industry studies published in 2024 and 2025, State Farm scores higher than Allstate on customer satisfaction. The J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study gave State Farm 716 out of 1,000, sixteen points above the industry average of 700. Allstate scored 691, below average. Erie Insurance led at 743. The J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, which measures overall customer satisfaction, placed State Farm in the top five in most regions while Allstate ranked below average in most regions and below State Farm in every region. State Farm also moved past Allstate in the J.D. Power 2025 Insurance Digital Experience Study. Both insurance companies have functional mobile apps and online tools, and State Farm’s currently score higher with customers in that study.
The NAIC complaint index shows a similar pattern. The baseline is 1.0; a higher number means more complaints than expected for a given size. State Farm’s auto complaint index runs below 1.0 across most NAIC reporting periods. Allstate’s runs above 1.0, meaning Allstate receives more complaints than expected relative to its size. The 2025 CRASH Network Report Card, which surveys auto repair shops, also placed State Farm above Allstate, though neither insurance company received a high overall grade. The single area where Allstate scored higher in U.S. News’ consumer survey is ease of filing claims; State Farm scored higher on ease of contacting customer service and on overall claims process satisfaction.
For shoppers who weight overall customer satisfaction or the claims process heavily, the published numbers favor State Farm. Both Allstate and State Farm carry strong financial stability ratings from AM Best (both A+ Superior), so financial strength is comparable between Allstate and State Farm. Safe drivers in particular tend to file claims rarely, which makes the satisfaction gap less consequential for safe drivers in practice than the headline numbers suggest. Allstate offers a strong claims app and digital tools that some safe drivers prefer despite the published score gap.
Coverage options: where Allstate has more specialty add-ons
This is where Allstate’s product lineup gets more attention in reviews. Both auto insurers cover the standard required protections: bodily injury liability, property damage liability, personal injury protection, medical payments, comprehensive coverage, collision, and uninsured/underinsured motorist. Both offer rideshare coverage, rental reimbursement, and roadside assistance as add-ons. Where State Farm coverage options and Allstate’s coverage options diverge is in the optional coverages and specialty add-ons.
| Coverage | State Farm | Allstate |
| Liability | Yes | Yes |
| Collision | Yes | Yes |
| Comprehensive coverage | Yes | Yes |
| Personal injury protection | Yes | Yes |
| Uninsured/underinsured motorist | Yes | Yes |
| Roadside assistance | Yes | Yes |
| Rental reimbursement | Yes | Yes |
| Rideshare coverage | Yes | Yes (Ride for Hire) |
| Gap insurance | No | Yes |
| Accident forgiveness | Add-on, qualifying customers | Standard for all customers |
| New car replacement | No | Yes |
| Sound system protection | No | Yes |
| Deductible Rewards | No | Yes |
| Mexico auto insurance | No | Yes |
| Steer Clear (under-25 program) | Yes | No |
| Pay-per-mile program | No | Yes (Milewise) |
The most-discussed coverage difference in reviews is gap insurance. If you finance or lease a vehicle and the car gets totaled while you still owe more than its actual cash value, gap pays the difference. Allstate sells it directly inside the car insurance policy. State Farm customers source gap from a dealership, the lender, or another insurance provider. Accident forgiveness is the second meaningful difference reviewers cite: Allstate includes it as a standard feature for all customers, while the Illinois insurance company offers it as an add-on, not standard, and not available in every state. New car replacement is Allstate’s third differentiator: if your car is totaled in the first 24 months and you have collision coverage, Allstate replaces it with the same make and model rather than paying actual cash value. The competing insurance company doesn’t offer an equivalent product.
State Farm’s coverage options take a simpler approach. The insurance company runs a deeper personal agent relationship through 19,000+ local agents (the largest agent network in the auto insurance industry), more flexible deductibles and coverage limits within standard insurance products, and the Steer Clear program for drivers under 25 that Allstate doesn’t match. Households that don’t need the specialty add-ons tend to find the State Farm coverage options sufficient.
Discounts: State Farm has a longer list, Allstate’s headline savings are larger
Both insurance providers offer the standard car insurance discounts: multi-policy bundle, good student, anti theft, paid-in-full, vehicle safety, and safe driving discounts. Both run telematics programs that reward safe driving habits and help households save money on premiums. The differences between Allstate and State Farm available discounts show up at the edges.
State Farm offers a defensive driving course discount, a low-mileage discount, a driver training discount, a loyalty discount, and a student-away-at-school discount. Allstate doesn’t offer those directly. State Farm’s Steer Clear program for under-25 drivers stacks on top of the good student discount and is one of the larger available discounts for young drivers. Allstate counters with a new car discount (up to 15%, one of the larger new car discounts in the industry), an Early Signing discount, and discounts for paperless billing and paying responsibly. State Farm’s anti theft discount applies when a vehicle has anti theft devices like alarms or tracking systems; Allstate stacks a similar anti theft discount with its vehicle safety feature discount.
Both telematics programs work differently. State Farm Drive Safe & Save tracks acceleration, speed, hard braking, and phone use, can run up to 30% off at renewal, and publicly will not raise your auto insurance premium. Allstate Drivewise also tracks driving habits and offers up to 15% off, but Drivewise can raise your rate if it detects unsafe driving habits in some states. For households on the fence about telematics, the Drive Safe & Save risk profile is gentler. Allstate’s Milewise pay per mile program is a category Drive Safe & Save doesn’t cover: a daily base rate plus a per-mile rate, suited to low-mileage commuters and remote workers. Milewise availability has been reduced in recent years, so check whether the pay per mile program is offered in your state.
The bundling discount is where State Farm’s price advantage compounds. State Farm’s average bundling discount is higher than Allstate’s, which means a customer combining auto insurance and homeowners insurance under State Farm tends to save more than a comparable Allstate customer.
Home insurance: State Farm posts lower average rates, Allstate has a wider discount list
The homeowners insurance comparison follows the auto pattern. State Farm’s average annual home insurance premium is $2,415 versus Allstate’s $2,715, per NerdWallet’s 2026 analysis. State Farm runs below the $2,490 national average for homeowners insurance; Allstate runs above. Both insurance companies receive an average rate of home insurance complaints relative to other U.S. insurers.
State Farm comes in cheaper for homeowners with a recent claim, brand-new houses, and most standard profiles. Allstate is cheaper for homeowners with poor credit and offers more available discounts overall, including discounts for green home upgrades, automatic payments, and responsible payment history. Allstate isn’t writing new homeowners insurance policies in California, Connecticut, or Florida. State Farm policies are unavailable for new auto in Massachusetts and Rhode Island, but broadly available for homeowners insurance.
State Farm’s home insurance policies generally include an extra cushion above your dwelling limit if rebuilding costs more than expected; Allstate offers similar coverage but charges extra for it. For most households, the Illinois insurer posts lower auto insurance and home insurance premiums and a stronger bundle discount, which can fit a range of insurance needs at a single insurance provider. Renters can also benefit: State Farm renters insurance averages about $13/mo, Allstate around $21/mo for similar coverage limits.
Which company tends to fit which situation
The Allstate vs State Farm decision usually comes down to which side of a few specific scenarios you fall on. State Farm tends to come in cheaper for clean records and good credit, teen drivers and parents adding teens (the $622/yr gap plus Steer Clear), drivers with a DUI or major incident on their record (less than half Allstate’s premium), shoppers prioritizing customer satisfaction or claims experience, anyone who values a personal agent relationship, and homeowners shopping for an auto insurance plus home insurance bundle.
Allstate tends to fit better in narrower scenarios: poor credit (consistently cheaper auto insurance quotes), drivers financing or leasing who want gap insurance built into the policy, low-mileage commuters who want true pay-per-mile pricing through Milewise, anyone who wants accident forgiveness as a standard feature, drivers buying a new car every two to three years who want new car replacement coverage, and shoppers who place high value on Allstate-specific add-ons like Deductible Rewards, sound system protection, or Mexico auto coverage.
If neither set of priorities applies cleanly, State Farm shows up as the cheaper starting quote in most published comparisons. Shoppers chasing one of Allstate’s specialty features tend to land at Allstate after pricing both.
How they compare to the rest of the market
State Farm and Allstate dominate the agent-driven auto insurance segment, but neither finishes at the top of every category. Shoppers prioritizing the absolute lowest car insurance rate often get cheaper insurance coverage from Geico or USAA (military families only). Geico’s national average for liability coverage is roughly $41/mo, the cheapest among large insurers per NerdWallet’s April 2026 analysis. Both run insurance coverage well below the national average for most driver profiles.
Households prioritizing customer satisfaction can get better insurance coverage from Erie (12 states plus D.C., 743 in J.D. Power claims), NJM (Mid-Atlantic), Amica (national), or USAA. All four outscore State Farm and Allstate in J.D. Power’s most recent claims study, though State Farm and Allstate beat them on coverage availability nationally.
Shoppers who want richer specialty coverage than Allstate offers might consider Travelers or Liberty Mutual, both of which offer comparable add-on lineups with rate competitiveness varying by state. Both Allstate and State Farm have invested heavily in mobile apps and online tools; the mobile apps from both insurance companies allow you to file claims, view ID cards, and manage payments. Shoppers who prioritize app-first management without an agent relationship might prefer the cleaner direct-to-consumer mobile apps from Geico or Progressive.
The practical move is to get auto insurance quotes from three or four insurance companies, including State Farm and at least one direct-to-consumer option for price comparison. Households that switched providers saved more than $460 per year on average per Consumer Reports data cited by Money. The car insurance industry is more competitive in 2026 than it has been in several years.
Frequently asked questions
Is State Farm or Allstate cheaper for car insurance?
State Farm tends to be cheaper. The average annual auto insurance premium is $2,204 versus Allstate’s $2,941, a $737 gap per U.S. News. State Farm posts cheaper average rates for nearly every driver profile, including clean records, teen drivers, senior drivers, and drivers with a DUI. The single consistent exception is poor credit, where Allstate sometimes prices lower.
Which has better customer service, Allstate or State Farm?
State Farm scores higher in published customer satisfaction studies. State Farm scored 716 in the J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study (above the 700 industry average); Allstate scored 691 (below average). State Farm ranked top-five in most regions of the J.D. Power 2025 Auto Insurance Study, while Allstate ranked below average in most regions. State Farm also has a lower NAIC complaint index than Allstate.
Does State Farm offer gap insurance?
No. State Farm does not offer traditional gap insurance for financed or leased vehicles. If you owe more on your vehicle than its actual cash value at the time of a total loss, you’d need to source gap coverage from your dealership, your lender, or a competitor. Allstate offers gap insurance directly inside its auto insurance policy, which is a coverage point worth weighing for households with new financed cars.
Which company is better for teen drivers?
State Farm tends to come in cheaper. State Farm averages $208/mo for a 16-year-old driver versus Allstate’s $371/mo, a roughly 44% gap. State Farm also offers the Steer Clear program for drivers under 25, which can save up to 20% with a safe-driving course completion. Allstate doesn’t have a direct equivalent. State Farm’s good student discount runs up to 25%, also higher than Allstate’s.
Which is cheaper for home insurance?
State Farm in most cases. State Farm averages $2,415 per year for $400,000 in dwelling coverage versus Allstate’s $2,715, per NerdWallet. State Farm runs below the $2,490 national average; Allstate runs above. Allstate is cheaper for homeowners with poor credit or those who qualify for several Allstate-specific home insurance discounts.
When does Allstate make more sense than State Farm?
When you specifically want gap insurance built into the policy, true pay-per-mile pricing through Milewise, accident forgiveness as a standard feature, new car replacement, or Allstate’s specialty add-ons (Deductible Rewards, sound system protection, Mexico auto). Households with poor credit also tend to get better Allstate auto insurance quotes than State Farm quotes.
The bottom line
For most shoppers in 2026, State Farm car insurance shows up as the cheaper option in the Allstate vs State Farm matchup, with stronger published customer satisfaction scores, fewer customer complaints relative to size, higher claims satisfaction scores, a larger local agent network, a more generous telematics program, and a stronger bundle discount when stacking auto insurance and home insurance policies. The case for Allstate car insurance is narrower but real: poor credit, a need for gap coverage or new car replacement, low-mileage commuters who want Milewise pay per mile pricing, and shoppers who value accident forgiveness as a standard feature. Allstate’s coverage discounts and add-ons can also tilt the math for households buying a new vehicle who want the new car discount.
Get car insurance quotes from both Allstate and State Farm before deciding. The State Farm and Allstate rate gap is large enough on average that the math will usually favor State Farm clearly, but the spread varies by state, vehicle, driving history, and credit. Both insurance policies sit above the national average for car insurance ($2,012/yr), so neither is the cheapest option in absolute terms. The honest framing of Allstate vs State Farm based on the data: State Farm tends to be the lower-cost starting quote for most households, and Allstate tends to fit households that specifically want one of its specialty features. Insurance policies are not interchangeable, and the cheapest insurance company isn’t always the best fit for every situation. Households who land in one of Allstate’s specialty scenarios may find the higher premium worthwhile. Most everyone else tends to see State Farm come in lower in published comparisons.
Ready to Compare?
Enter your ZIP code to see your options in minutes.